
The UK Government announced that the next EU-UK Summit will take place on 20 November in Brussels. During the summit, both sides will outline the concluded Sanitary and Phytosanitary agreement. This will see Great Britain align with EU rules on plant and animal health, aspects of animal welfare, organics and food labelling.
Throughout the negotiations, NFU Scotland has worked closely with both the UK and Scottish Governments, our Brussels representatives through the British Agriculture Bureau, and a wide range of industry stakeholders to ensure that the interests of Scottish farmers and crofters are fully represented.
While the details of the final agreement will not be published until after the summit, our assessment is that the agreement has the potential to deliver significant net benefits for Scottish agriculture.
The agreement should make it easier for Scottish products, particularly red meat and dairy, to access the EU market by reducing trade barriers and costs. Scottish seed potato exports to the EU should also resume, providing a welcome boost to the sector. Importantly, the British market should be protected from imports of Brazilian meat products that do not meet equivalent production standards, a key ask of the UK farming unions. In addition, the EU is expected to strengthen origin labelling from next year, a long-standing priority of NFUS.
However, these opportunities must be balanced against several important regulatory concerns, which we have been pressing negotiators to address.
Plant protection Products: There has been divergence between Great Britain and the EU on plant protection products. British growers have access to three new chemicals not currently available in the EU. We are calling for these GB authorisations to be retained until an EU decision is made.
There are also 13 active substances no longer available for use in the EU which are still available in GB. It is essential that a ‘cliff edge’ scenario with no transition period is avoided.
Mycotoxins: The EU has lower legal maximum limits for certain mycotoxins in cereals used for food and drink processing than in GB. The full implications of alignment are unknown, as the British supply chain has not yet needed to test against these lower limits.
Scotland’s uniquely challenging wet and mild weather is a risk factor for higher levels of mycotoxin contamination in oat crops. We have pressed UK negotiators to secure sufficient flexibility within the agreement, allowing for appropriate technical adaptations that reflect Scotland's unique growing conditions. An adequate transition period will also be essential to allow supply chains time to adjust.
UHF-EID: NFU Scotland has been calling for the introduction of Ultra-high Frequency Electronic Identification (UHF-EID) for over 20 years. We believe that EU legislation is sufficiently flexible to allow the use of UHF-EID, and we have consistently made this case to both the UK and Scottish Governments.
Animal health: The EU had a wide-ranging overhaul of animal health legislation in 2016, leading to divergence with domestic rules. This includes stricter EU rules on antimicrobial use. Given the UK’s very low use of antimicrobials, we do not believe further alignment with EU legislation is necessary in this area.
We have also identified several areas of divergence in animal disease control, including stricter EU rules on bovine TB and avian influenza. NFU Scotland has called on the UK and Scottish Governments to take a pragmatic and proportionate approach to the interpretation and implementation of any new requirements, maintaining high animal health standards without creating unnecessary burdens for farmers.
Decision shaping: Finally, it is essential that the UK secures meaningful opportunities to influence future EU regulatory decisions. If Great Britain is to dynamically align with EU rules in key areas, Scottish and UK farmers must have a voice in the development of future legislation that will affect their businesses.
Securing robust transition periods for any future regulatory changes will also be critical, allowing farmers, processors and supply chains sufficient time to adapt.
NFU Scotland’s priorities throughout the negotiations have been clear. We recognise the opportunities that the SPS agreement could bring. However, these benefits must not come at the expense of Scottish farming and crofting realities. As the negotiations reach their final stages, we urge UK negotiators to continue pushing for these positions, which would protect the interests of Scottish farmers and crofters.